7 News Belize

Mayans Claim Victory, Greg Ch’oc Questions It
posted (April 21, 2015)
The Maya Leaders Alliance today sent out a press release claiming victory in the Caribbean Court of Justice. A release says that the Court "yesterday reaffirmed that the Maya Indigenous People of southern Belize have rights to lands they have customarily used and occupied."

It adds quote, "the judgement....requires the government to demarcate and register Maya village lands, and protect them against incursions (while) undertaking to adopt the necessary 'legislative, administrative, and/or other measures' to that end." In 12 months the parties will report on implementation.

The release adds, that in the past the Government has vigorously contested the assertions of Maya Customary land rights. The release says that, quote, "government reversed this position and came to an agreement that was the basis of the Court's judgment by consent." They note that the Maya's claim for compensation for damages is the only matter outstanding.

It closes by saying, quote, "The Maya People's victory....is a victory for all marginalized peoples in Belize and worldwide."

But is it really that simple? Greg Ch'oc says it isn't. Though he's away studying, Cho'oc sent the media a statement today saying, he has strong reservations about the decision, to have the government settle the outstanding issues rather than to have the court issue a ruling. He asks "What exactly was settled at the case management conference yesterday?" He notes that the lead attorneys for both parties weren't saying the same thing - in his opinion.

He says he reserves his optimism because, quote, "I do not think the Government is prepared to effect the substance of the legal changes required."

Home | Archives | Downloads/Podcasts | Advertise | Contact Us

7 News Belize